Phoenix Business Journal - by Mike Sunnucks Friday, October 23, 2009
The next shoe to drop in the legal fight over special tax breaks and subsidies for developers could be over the 100 percent tax exemptions ponied up for high-profile projects such as ASU SkySong in Scottsdale and enjoyed by professional sports teams.
That action could come after the Arizona Supreme Court decides whether a $97 million tax break for the
The first is a lawsuit expected to be filed over government property lease excise taxes, or GPLETs. These funding mechanisms allow government entities that own land to lease it back to private developers and businesses, which then pay lower-than-normal property taxes. The
Cheuvront wants to sue to try to stop the tax breaks. Clint Bolick, attorney for the Goldwater Institute, said the conservative think tank also is looking at other tax arrangements to determine whether they are legal.
“We’re just beginning to burrow deeply into GPLETs,” Bolick said. “To the extent that lease rates are below market after tax benefits are taken into consideration, it may represent an illegal subsidy, and also may violate equal protection of the law if similarly situated tenants are paying more in private buildings.”
As that case works its way through the courts, the same skeptics want to go after entities including SkySong, the
None of those arrangements are considered GPLETs, though that mechanism has been used extensively for downtown
Real estate developers and business interests say striking down the CityNorth subsidy, GPLETs or other tax incentives would discourage investments and economic development.
‘Attacks will continue’
Grady Gammage Jr., a partner with Gammage & Burnham PLC, is representing developer Thomas J. Klutznick & Co. in the CityNorth case. He expects the GPLET and property tax battles to be waged on the political front, with restrictions proposed by the Arizona Legislature. He said critics of tax breaks and special incentives will continue to look for ways to bring the issue to the forefront.
“I think the attacks will continue,” he said.
Gammage said some projects, such as development around
Tim Lawless, Arizona Chapter president of NAIOP, a national commercial real estate organization, said property tax incentives need to be on the table for redevelopment projects, especially those in blighted areas and those attracting high-wage jobs. But he addded that such tax breaks should be used judiciously so as not to require higher property taxes on others.
Bolick and Cheuvront argue that special tax arrangements are unfair because they benefit favored businesses or developers.
Never assessed
SkySong sits on land owned by the city of
Maricopa County Assessor’s Office data shows the previous owners of the site, including real estate developer Steve Ellman, paid between $52,000 and $189,000 a year in property taxes on the Los Arcos site from 1993 to 2004.
Ellman sold the site to the ASU Foundation in 2005 for $41.5 million. The foundation then sold the land to the city of
SkySong is being developed by the
Ellman had wanted to build an arena for the Phoenix Coyotes on the site and then later add a big-box retail center, both of which likely would have been subject to property taxes. Those plans were rejected.
